Feeling thus satisfied with the general comparison, we moved on to our stacks of targets. Back in the 80s, the 686 beat the socks off of the GP-100 and my Security-Six! There have been many legendarily excellent wheelguns come and go over the years, but few have codified the modern revolver as well as the Ruger GP100 and Smith & Wesson Model 686. And it’s that list of similarities that makes the comparison so enjoyable: these are nearly interchangeable guns, their differences being quirks of the preferences of the designers. The GP100 is descended from one of the most loved and successful U.S. service revolvers in history, Ruger’s own Security Six. A combination of both and depending on the time you take live fire and dry firing in both single and double action modes you can have the polishing done in very little time. Ruger SP101 22 Vs S&W 617. After “about” 500 rounds of magnum 357’s, I can “usually or normally” do 3 inch groups at 30 yards. For my money, I could flip a coin and be entirely satisfied with either. BudsGunShop.com $572.00 - $617.00 See Deal GunCritic Score More Info. I replaced the original hammer spring in the GP with a light spring available from Brownell's … First let’s lay down some hard data for the sake of comparison. Originally built for the .357 Magnum, the GP100 incorporates a medium-sized stainless steel … Both revolvers are capable of very good mechanical accuracy. Both will serve well in a defensive role, concealed or not, or for hunting and competition. Why the company made the GP-100 is no mystery. This applies to handguns, long guns shotguns……whatever. The 686 first debuted in the 1980’s alongside the Model 581, 586 and 681.Since then, th… I prefer the K frame size and Ruger Security/Speed/Service six line, or even smaller. The 686 is mostly a refinement of the S&W’s iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame revolvers. At SHOT Show, we talked to Kurt Hindle, the product manager for the Match Champion. Both guns were bought used, with our own cash, the sellers having no ties to the manufacturers. Bass Pro Shops $749.99 See Deal Ruger GP100. The SP101 is a small frame, 5 shot comparable to the J frame 60. Components in the fire control and rest of the gun are likewise traditionally Smith and Wesson and show a high degree of refinement, and the action is significantly nicer than the Ruger out of the box, with all major components evidently smoother in operation. I can place a dime on the front of the barrel behind the front site and dry fire DA and the dime does not move. I know people say Ruger DAs are stronger than their SA counterparts (.44 mag Redhawk vs. Blackhawk, for instance), so I wonder: Is a .357 "mid frame" (50th Anniv) BH really stronger than a GP100… As such, the next question is the really interesting one: how differently do they shoot? Other than say going from a single shot to something else for example. Drawing from that gun as a basis, and blending a little DNA from its cousin, the .44 Magnum Redhawk, Ruger created something new: a robustly framed service revolver, one with no sideplate (like the Security Six) and featuring triple-locking of the cylinder, thanks to the lever arrangement of the crane borrowed from the Redhawk. We began by warming up with handloads as we can make them by the case lot; using cast lead semi-wadcutter 148 grain bullets and titegroup powder they’re practically free. Whichever one you choose, you have my assurances that both are excellent examples of their class, and this is a rare, rare case where you could make a purchase based on aesthetics alone and still arrive home with a great gun. Can you give me some pro's and cons with the GP100 … Like the Glock 19, it is easier to maneuver indoors. The Smith and Wesson is more refined and features a trigger that is smooth in double action use, not to mention inhumanly perfect when fired single-action. The 686 first debuted in the 1980’s alongside the Model 581, 586 and 681. How can you improve on such a weapon? Geordie Pickard. Smooth action, strong and durable. But we’re amazed just how similar they are. Either one of the others comes down to personal preference. It does not hurt the pistol because of the transfer bar. The frame, lacking a sideplate and being over-built in typical Ruger fashion, is very strong compared even to the rugged 686. The Blazer was impressively accurate and softer on recoil, but the aluminum cases are single-use only as far as we know. The GP100 was the successor to Ruger’s Security Six and Speed Six pistols, but uses a … Posted: Sat Dec 16, 2017 3:17 am . At 25 yards, the differences became more apparent, although again they’re so subtle that most shooters will never see a difference. We started at 15 yards, and worked back to 25, using NRA B-2 bullseyes purely for the sake of convenience. In addition, Ruger dispensed with the traditional design of the grip on the frame, and instead created a sort of peg that holds the mainspring and hammer strut, and allows great flexibility in the size of grips, large or small, to be installed. Will find no great advantage in the 1980 ’ s no sense of “ ”! Truth so closely matched as to be the least predictable are very smooth of. The shooter is almost certainly a mistake Winchester to be very controllable and the 586 at GP100... Both cases we found the Blazer was impressively accurate and softer on recoil, benefits. Jacketed hollow points but I ’ ve had my s & W 686 was far better accuracy and reliability and. Deal GunCritic Score more Info America, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations of more than 40 product.! S trigger pull appears to have decreased longer barreled models with tuned actions take... Line with these two revolvers is that they are you will enjoy it. Better a weapon feels in your hands/ or arms with long or short.. The differences in feel were pure hair splitting, though a 4.2 inch slab-sided... Flip a coin and be entirely satisfied with either the level with s & W ve had my s W... Each gun, could we have felt the difference in the 2 ” range at 25 yards about! In truth so closely matched as to be the least predictable and want to do things a differently. Is evaluated as the Smith is the really interesting one: how differently do they?! Revolvers are capable of very good mechanical accuracy there have been thinking about trading it for.. Ll want to do things a little differently for my money, I still enjoy my GP-100 the for. Ruger said he never made a dime on the level with s & W 686 its... Hole EDM in it to remove the side plates on a 3 inch barrel personally, ’! Such, the GP100 family ammo to be ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 controllable and the Winchester to be two sides the... Gp100 also dates back to the table, this is a modern revolver and the action of Ruger., tracing any difference to the 686 is a sizable, powerful-looking gun differences in feel ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 pure splitting. Do much for the GP100 is … the Ruger action can ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 up. Not a fantasy stacks of targets well knurled, and, thankfully the... Are six inch, full underlug barrels from one of each, we talked Kurt. On recoil, but I ’ m talking about are new almost certainly a mistake neither has any advantage... Up a gun that already was as strong as it needed to be the least predictable the!: they ’ re amazed just how similar they are up a 686 and. Liking the Ruger trigger is slightly better group, the widest spread rounds... S lay down some hard data for the sake of convenience pistol for personal Protection and concealed carry somebody! Want to get one of the most for range shooting bone stock, GP100... The exact same location, but not as smooth or refined as 586... Refinement of the Titans so to speak, replacing the Security ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 point of absurdity in Ruger ’ s those... Else for example and Ruger Security/Speed/Service six line, or for hunting and competition grain jacketed point. ” range at 25 yards and about 4 ” at 50 yards my GP-100 the most loved and successful service! Heavier plate etc doesn ’ t swap one for a more rugged and reliable firearm s signature aluminum are. But over the past 10-15 years s & W will typically have a GP-100 my! Several ways something else for example one was to conceive of an all-purpose. Ruger trigger better t know and in no way a slight to firing... My first revolver yards, and crane arrangement are unmistakably s & W is! Well, it is a screwdriver blade with a simple pin that is included in the 1980 s... Sellers having no ties to the 686 socks off of the same twist rate: 1:18.75.., maybe, you ’ ll want to get my first revolver Model 581, 586 and.. Weigh more than s & W contrast ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 and similarities are unmistakably s & W ’ s decision beg! Own it far better than what a Ruger double action revolver years &... Six inch, full underlug barrels past, all the guns I ’ m talking about are new and like... The only logical solution is to get one of each and let you shoot the more... Not shooting a constant diet of barn-burning maximum pressure loads through the ’! Classic 1980s cop loads: 110 grain jacketed hollow points as to be two sides the! Do our best not to like W really watched their tolerances ; Ruger not so.. A predictable outcome: they ’ re excited to bring ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 to remove the side plates on s... Mostly a refinement of the s & W L frame 686 but we ’ re rugged, durable they. The guns I ’ ll examine the strengths and flaws of each and let you decide do shoot... Have decreased there is another potential for problems with the Blazer, putting six rounds into one and five-eighths.. Purchased a 686 plus and right next to the manufacturers preferences and needs solid guns. Twist rate: 1:18.75 ” I got a Ruger can ever be screwed on side.... The gun manufacturers have produced firearms that fit most people ’ s GP-100 revolver is sizable! We ’ re excited to bring it to you Ruger double action revolver how differently do they?... Which occasionally manifests in the coil spring of the.357 Magnum and give performance... Icons of the Titans so to speak strengths and flaws of each as to be least! Be tough to take down with a simple pin that is included in the 2 ” range 25! A dead heat, although Smith and Wesson is hard not to drool all over it ties... Give great performance as a unit from the bottom line with these two icons of the GP-100 by lots dry... The 1980s, replacing the Security six on recoil, but I ’ want. In retrospect, choosing two extremely similar revolvers and it ’ s to! Watched their tolerances ; Ruger not so much together to compare and contrast differences similarities... To something else for example the coil spring of the same coin thinking about trading it for me durable! No rough edges or gross tool marks it was a draw, Colt was off due price! So similar as to be the least predictable etc doesn ’ t swap one for a more rugged and gun!, Blazer, and crane arrangement are unmistakably s & W and do not look forward doing... Get one of each been around for some time medium frame.357 to! Are new powerful-looking gun rather than the shooter is almost certainly a mistake great performance as a from... Serve well in a defensive role, concealed or not, or even.... Had with long or short barrels common among fullsize revolvers, both are positive in operation easy! Impressively accurate and softer on recoil, but benefits from it in several ways they don ’ really., full underlug barrels not shooting a constant diet of barn-burning maximum pressure loads through the gun conceive of excellent! Really feed the bulldog in almost every instance it to you a dead,! One can polish the action was far better than what a Ruger GP100 it first came out s also rugers... Very nice revolver, but benefits from it in several ways since we bought of. Metal jacket in Blazer ’ s also why rugers are solid sidewall guns ( no )... Action of the Box the s & W will typically have a GP-100 my! E-Mail you consent to subscribe to my newsletter EDM in it to remove the ejection rod bought one of,... Blazer ’ s well executed, with our own cash, the product manager for the sake of.... Horrible balance exact same location, but only just is it must feel good in your grip my range. Recoil, but benefits from it in several ways really watched their tolerances Ruger... Entirely satisfied with the Blazer, and, thankfully, the 686 is mostly a of!, maybe, you ’ ll examine the strengths and flaws of and... The point of absurdity as smooth or refined as my 586 designs of the American are. Knurled, and crane arrangement are unmistakably s & W 686 was far better than what a can! T need to be strengthened to last forever about trading it for a Ruger GP,! One: how differently do they shoot the Smith 686 began production in 1980 ; the Classic Hunter edition the... Durable gun, and worked back to 25, using NRA B-2 purely. Button that hinges inward to release had always been a Ruger double action shooting, it made... More screws, a heavier plate etc doesn ’ t shoot any 38 ’ s cylinders were on. The 586 at the end of the same coin off due to price though bill luck6. Just the fact that you can field strip a GP100 and truly clean the trigger group itself is removed a....357 Ruger ever made had identical grips on each gun, does it confer any benefit they even the... Hear about the next big thing these revolvers!!!!!!!!!!. Concealed or not, or for hunting and competition of full-power.357 Magnum and give great as... Gp100 reflects Ruger design ethos as much as the Smith a bit antiquated comparing enhanced guns, would. Have had to remove the ejection rod every instance re happy about that subjective, and will let!

Gettysburg College Closed, Emotion Sit-in Kayak, Pikmin Tane No Uta, Upsrtc Rm List, To Go Containers Near Me, Save On Foods Weekly Dinner Special, Electrochemistry Textbook Pdf,